Keep the Nightlight On: Babysitter vs. Deadly Parents

Hosts Robin and Scott read a Halloween-ready Reddit story called "Keep the Nightlight On," about babysitter Claire, an anxious boy named Jake, and a seemingly perfect family whose staged accidents— a peanut in the mash, a sparking game console, and a malfunctioning nightlight—hide a murderous plan.

The episode mixes banter and commentary as the twist unravels: Claire foils attempts on the child but is tragically killed by a dart launched from the nightlight that was meant for Jake. Short, tense, and darkly ironic, it’s a chilling listen with a sinister payoff.

Don't miss out on the fun – subscribe, follow, and rate 5 stars 

Click the link below to subscribe and follow on all platforms and to email us about anything, we'll be happy to hear from you.

https://linktr.ee/laughwhileyouscream

Music by Jeremy Blake

ALSO check out IN TIME CRIME If you are a true crime fan. https://linktr.ee/intimecrime